Song Evaluations and Coaching Services

Choose a song evaluation coach. Submit your song for a critique. Get written feedback on your song from a music industry pro.
Find coaches by genre: Viewing all coaches

How Song Evaluations Work

Getting professional feedback on your song is easy:

  1. Browse coaches below. Compare each coach's genres, bio, philosophy, and turnaround time.
  2. Click "Submit Song to Coach." You'll then choose your evaluation type: Comprehensive, Quickie, or Rewrite (if eligible).
  3. Select your song. Choose a song from your Song Locker to submit.
  4. Receive your written evaluation. We'll email you when it's complete, and it will always be available in your Song Evaluation activity page.

Browse Song Coaches Below:

  1.  
  2. Song Coach #1318
    Genres: Adult Contemporary, Cabaret, Childrens, Contemporary Country, Country, Film/TV/Media, Instrumental, Jazz, Musical Theater, Pop, R&B, Singer Songwriter.
    Evaluation Turnaround: Usually 7 days or less
    Coach Bio
    Multiple Emmy Award-winning songwriter for PBS/BBC Children's songs, documentary scores, and hit R&B songs. This song evaluation coach is comfortable... (show more)
    This song evaluation coach is a professional songwriter and the winner of 4 EMMY Awards for PBS/BBC children's songs and film/documentary scores as well as two Gold Records for songs written for R&B legend, Millie Jackson. Former Jazz Record label head and has scored numerous project oriented orchestral pieces performed worldwide.

    AI policy: Songs that are created using AI for any of its elements fall into a different form of critique than songs that were inspired and completely written by a human (you). As a coach, I prefer to comment on the latter. So if you have used AI to help you write your song, please let me know ahead of time so I can critique the song with that element in mind. This is to enhance your skills as the creator of the particular part of the song that you are responsible for. (show less)
    Coach Philosophy
    My motto and key phrase is - the art of songwriting is re-writing. I give honest, clear and concise song evaluations in a kind encouraging way. I real... (show more)
    My motto and key phrase is - the art of songwriting is re-writing. I give honest, clear and concise song evaluations in a kind encouraging way. I really want YOU to learn and to become a great songwriter. My years of songwriting experience gives me an objective point of view toward the craft of songwriting and helping you write your songs. I very much enjoy working with songwriters of all levels. And most important, my love for the process is what I share with you. (show less)

    Coach #1318 - Turnaround Time

    This coach usually turns around evaluations in 7 days or less. There may be some occasions if the coach is traveling or during holidays when this turnaround could be slightly longer.

    Additional Comment: I usually get to song evaluations within a week of receiving them. The exceptions are when I am professionally committed to another project with a deadline or composing a new work. Thank you and I look forward to listening to your songs.

    Coach #1318 - Temporarily Unavailable

    This coach is temporarily unavailable for submissions during the dates listed on the page.

  3. Song Coach #1683
    Genres: Childrens, Christian, Christian Contemporary (CCM), Christian Praise/Worship, Contemporary Country, Country, Inspirational, Pop, R&B, Singer Songwriter, Traditional Country.
    Evaluation Turnaround: Usually 14 days or less
    Coach Bio
    Hit songwriter with multiple #1 singles in Country and other songs recorded in R&B, Rock, Inspirational, Film and TV, and Musical Theatre specializes... (show more)
    This song evaluation coach has two #1 singles for the iconic country band 'Alabama' as well as other songs recorded in R&B, Rock, Inspirational, Film and TV, and scored for Musical Theatre. This coach is also an actor and can be seen in television and film. They are open to answering career guidance questions. (show less)
    Coach Philosophy
    I'm here to help you reach your goals for your songs sharing what I've learned as a writer in country, pop, Christian, inspirational, musical theatre,... (show more)
    I'm here to help you reach your goals for your songs sharing what I've learned as a writer in country, pop, Christian, inspirational, musical theatre, classical music and sync. (show less)

    Coach #1683 - Turnaround Time

    This coach usually turns around evaluations in 14 days or less. There may be some occasions if the coach is traveling or during holidays when this turnaround could be slightly longer.

    Additional Comment: Sometimes it may take 14 days to get your evaluation. My goal is to get it to you sooner than that if at all possible.

    Coach #1683 - Temporarily Unavailable

    This coach is temporarily unavailable for submissions during the dates listed on the page.

  4. Song Coach #2245
    Genres: Alternative, Contemporary Country, Country, Dance, Film/TV/Media, Pop, R&B, Rock, Singer Songwriter, Urban.
    Evaluation Turnaround: No new submissions
    Coach Bio
    Please do not submit AI demos or AI melodies to this coach. Prefers simple worktapes or demos with musicians. Two-time Emmy Award-winning songwriter a... (show more)
    This song evaluation coach is a two-time Emmy-Award winning songwriter and producer with over 4000 song placements in film and TV who has written hit songs in multiple genres for artists all over the world, as well as having over 4000 film and TV song placements. This coach has been publishing and placing her own catalog for most of her career and is well-versed business issues pertaining to the music industry. (show less)
    Coach Philosophy
    My song coaching philosophy is one of empowerment and inspiration along with some real and straightforward honesty about what I believe is important i... (show more)
    My song coaching philosophy is one of empowerment and inspiration along with some real and straightforward honesty about what I believe is important in the way of crafting a great song - for personal satisfaction, of course - but also for commercial success. (show less)
    Unavailable for new submissions:

    07/10/2026 - 09/01/2026

    Coach #2245 - Turnaround Time

    normal I try to get your song feedback done in less than 7 days...sometimes longer if I'm in the studio. Thank you for sending me your wonderful songs and lyrics. It is an honor to coach them! Musically and Lyrically Yours!

    Coach #2245 - Temporarily Unavailable

    This coach is temporarily unavailable for submissions during the dates listed on the page.

  5. Song Coach #3012
    Genres: Contemporary Country, Country, Honky Tonk, Pop, Singer Songwriter, Southern Rock, Traditional Country.
    Evaluation Turnaround: Usually 7 days or less
    Coach Bio
    Hit songwriter, music publisher, artist, and producer. As a songwriter, this coach has garnered close to 2 million airplay spins on radio, Specializin... (show more)
    This song evaluation coach is an award-winning songwriter and music publisher, artist and producer. As both songwriter and music publisher, this coach is a member of BMI's millionaire club with airplays well over 2 million with singles on major labels and 2 Grammy-winning artists. (show less)
    Coach Philosophy
    "Straight up." If you want people to tell you how amazing a songwriter you are, keep playing songs for your friends and family. If you want constructi... (show more)
    "Straight up." If you want people to tell you how amazing a songwriter you are, keep playing songs for your friends and family. If you want constructive song evaluations, advice, encouragement, and real tools to improve your songwriting and pitching, talk to me. (show less)

    Coach #3012 - Turnaround Time

    This coach usually turns around evaluations in 7 days or less. There may be some occasions if the coach is traveling or during holidays when this turnaround could be slightly longer.

    Additional Comment: I try to turn around the feedback in under a week unless there are extenuating circumstances. Thanks.

    Coach #3012 - Temporarily Unavailable

    This coach is temporarily unavailable for submissions during the dates listed on the page.

  6. Song Coach #3762
    Genres: Country, Film/TV/Media, Pop, R&B, Rock, Singer Songwriter, World.
    Evaluation Turnaround: Usually 7 days or less
    Coach Bio
    Hit songwriter with over 200 recordings by major label Pop, Urban, and R&B artists and film and TV, specializes in song evaluations for Pop, Rock, R&B... (show more)
    This song evaluation coach is a hit songwriter with over 200 songs recorded across multiple genres by various artists around the world (Celine Dion, Notorious B.I.G, Cyndi Lauper, Patti LaBelle, Gloria Estefan, Oak Ridge Boys, Journey, and more), and significant credits in Film/TV, including ("Top Gun," "Fame," "Coming to America," and more). (show less)
    Coach Philosophy
    I consider myself a real colleague and advocate for songwriters and will give whatever I feel is needed in each individual song evaluation -- from "to... (show more)
    I consider myself a real colleague and advocate for songwriters and will give whatever I feel is needed in each individual song evaluation -- from "tough songwriter love" in a direct fashion, to being a cheerleader. I enjoy working with all levels of writers and have been known to throw in some stories from my own songwriting career when needed. (show less)

    Coach #3762 - Turnaround Time

    This coach usually turns around evaluations in 7 days or less. There may be some occasions if the coach is traveling or during holidays when this turnaround could be slightly longer.

    Additional Comment: Usually, I'm able to get to song evaluations quickly, often within the same day unless I'm traveling internationally, or have a particularly hectic week which can sometimes put me a bit behind on my turnaround. I work hard at being prompt about all song evaluations submitted.

    Coach #3762 - Temporarily Unavailable

    This coach is temporarily unavailable for submissions during the dates listed on the page.

  7. Song Coach #4146
    Genres: Adult Contemporary, Christian, Christian Contemporary (CCM), Christian Praise/Worship, Contemporary Country, Country, Film/TV/Media, Indie, Inspirational, Pop, Singer Songwriter.
    Evaluation Turnaround: Usually 14 days or less
    Coach Bio
    Award-winning songwriter, artist, in-demand demo singer and touring back-up singer/musician, specializes in evaluating songs for Indie singer-songwrit... (show more)
    This song evaluation coach is an award-winning songwriter, artist, in-demand demo singer, and touring back-up singer/musician who performs all over the world. A former staff songwriter with numerous songs placed in film and TV shows as well as major label artists covering her songs, including a 2017 Grammy-winning album by Reba McEntire. This coach has been in the studio and/or toured live playing keyboards, guitar, mandolin, and singing background vocals with major artists including Rodney Crowell, Lee Ann Womack, Pam Tillis, and Christopher Cross. (show less)
    Coach Philosophy
    I love helping songwriters learn the craft of writing a great song, but I also try to find ways to raise the emotional element. I will be sensitive to... (show more)
    I love helping songwriters learn the craft of writing a great song, but I also try to find ways to raise the emotional element. I will be sensitive to your connection to your creation but honest in what I think the potential is with each song evaluation you submit. (show less)

    Coach #4146 - Turnaround Time

    This coach usually turns around evaluations in 14 days or less. There may be some occasions if the coach is traveling or during holidays when this turnaround could be slightly longer.

    Additional Comment: I try to get them done within 7 days, but sometimes it takes longer, depending on my schedule.

    Coach #4146 - Temporarily Unavailable

    This coach is temporarily unavailable for submissions during the dates listed on the page.

  8. Song Coach #12807
    Genres: Adult Contemporary, Christian Contemporary (CCM), Contemporary Country, Country, Pop, R&B, Rock, Singer Songwriter, Southern Rock, Traditional Country.
    Evaluation Turnaround: Usually 14 days or less
    Coach Bio
    Former A&R Director with Warner Brothers Records, responsibilities included finding great material for artists. Specializes in evaluating songs for Co... (show more)
    This song evaluation coach started his music career as a touring singer/songwriter which eventually evolved into a ten-year stint as Warner Bros. Records Director of A&R in Nashville. His responsibilities included signing and developing new artists and finding great material for established artists resulting in multiple Grammy awards for Emmylou Harris and others. (show less)
    Coach Philosophy
    I love songs. My coaching philosophy is one of encouragement along with straightforward honesty about what I believe is important in the way of crafti... (show more)
    I love songs. My coaching philosophy is one of encouragement along with straightforward honesty about what I believe is important in the way of crafting a great song - for personal satisfaction, of course - but also for commercial success. (show less)

    Coach #12807 - Turnaround Time

    This coach usually turns around evaluations in 14 days or less. There may be some occasions if the coach is traveling or during holidays when this turnaround could be slightly longer.

    Additional Comment: I evaluate songs within 7 days.

    Coach #12807 - Temporarily Unavailable

    This coach is temporarily unavailable for submissions during the dates listed on the page.

Song Evaluations & Coaching

Receive personalized feedback on your songs or lyrics from your choice of SongU coaches. 1 credit = $1.

Cost of Song EvaluationLite
(credits)
Platinum
(credits)
Comprehensive - Our most detailed evaluation with letter grades and written feedback in every category. Ideal for first-time submissions or when you want in-depth coaching.2518
Quickie - A fast, one-pass evaluation with letter grades and a concise summary highlighting your song's strengths and opportunities.1510
Rewrite – Re-evaluate your revised song with the same coach after you've applied their suggestions. Available within 60 days of your Comprehensive Evaluation.1510